Interview Insights:
Rail Analysis: What factors should a metro developer consider to evaluate a metro proposal for its financial lucrativeness? In that context, where do the Kanpur and Lucknow Metro expansions stand?
Shri Sushil Kumar: Evaluating the financial lucrativeness of a metro proposal involves a comprehensive analysis of several key factors.
Demand Forecasting is a fundamental aspect. Developers need to project expected daily ridership by examining demographic studies, population growth trends, urbanization patterns, and travel behavior analyses. Additionally, understanding commuter patterns through origin-destination studies helps identify high-traffic corridors and potential usage, ensuring the metro service effectively meets the needs of the population.
Conducting a Cost-Benefit Analysis is equally essential. This entails creating detailed estimates for construction costs, including civil works, station construction, rolling stock, and related infrastructure.
Developers must also forecast ongoing operational expenses, covering maintenance, staffing, and energy costs. Revenue projections are critical as well; potential income from ticket sales, advertising, and ancillary services must be evaluated to gauge the overall financial outlook
Securing Funding and Investment is a vital component of any metro project. Developers should identify available government support or public funding to aid construction and operational costs. Exploring opportunities for Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) can also help mitigate financial risks, ensuring a stable funding framework.
Economic viability plays a significant role in assessing a metro proposal. Developers must establish a competitive fare structure that balances affordability for users with the need for revenue sufficiency. Furthermore, the long-term economic impact of the metro system should be considered, particularly its potential to contribute to local economic growth, increase property values, and create jobs in the region.
The Social and Environmental Impact of the metro project is another critical factor. Evaluating sustainability considerations, such as the environmental benefits of reduced traffic congestion and pollution, aligns the project with governmental sustainability goals. Ensuring social inclusion by making the metro accessible to all socio-economic groups can potentially enhance ridership and garner community support.
Infrastructure Integration is essential for the overall success of the metro system. Developers must assess last-mile connectivity, ensuring effective integration with other modes of transport, such as buses and auto-rickshaws, to provide comprehensive mobility solutions. Planning efficient interchange facilities will further enhance passenger convenience and usage.
Finally, Risk Assessment is crucial to identify potential challenges. Developers should recognize construction risks, including possible delays and cost overruns, and formulate strategies to mitigate these issues. Additionally, market risks, such as economic fluctuations that could impact ridership and funding, must be carefully considered.
In examining the current status of the Kanpur and Lucknow metro expansions, we find that both projects have made significant strides. The Lucknow Metro, particularly the North-South Corridor, was completed in just 4.5 years and includes 23 kilometers of track with 21 stations. This timely completion not only saved costs but also reflects strong demand forecasting and planning, enhancing its financial viability.
On the other hand, the Kanpur Metro is advancing with two proposed corridors totaling around 32 kilometers. The inauguration of a 9-kilometer priority section demonstrates the project’s successful implementation and highlights its potential for financial sustainability.
In conclusion, the expansions of both the Kanpur and Lucknow metros exhibit effective planning, timely execution, and a focus on integrating various transport modalities. Their financial success will ultimately depend on sustained demand, strategic fare policies, and ongoing public and private investment. As these projects continue to evolve, they promise to transform urban mobility in Uttar Pradesh.
Kanpur Metro
Rail Analysis: With reference to these metros, to what extent do their alignments impact their operations? Were these designed to deliver the highest returns, or did practical considerations impede the choice of the best alignment?
Shri Sushil Kumar: The alignment of metro lines plays a crucial role in the operational efficiency and financial returns of transportation projects, and this holds true for the metro systems in Uttar Pradesh. As UPMRC expands its metro network in cities like Lucknow, Kanpur, and Agra, the chosen alignments significantly influence both operational capabilities and the overall effectiveness of the service provided.
Alignment Considerations and Their Impact
When planning the metro alignments, UPMRC had to balance several factors to ensure practicality while aiming for maximum returns. The primary goal was to connect key urban areas and major transport terminals, such as airports and railway stations, to facilitate seamless passenger movement.
For instance, the Lucknow Metro’s North-South Corridor, spanning 23 kilometers, connects vital points like Chaudhary Charan Singh Airport and major bus stands. This strategic positioning enhances accessibility for commuters, thereby increasing ridership and, in turn, potential revenue.
Lucknow Metro
In Kanpur, the proposed two corridors of approximately 32 kilometers are designed to alleviate traffic congestion while serving densely populated areas. Corridor-1, which runs from IIT Kanpur to Naubasta, has a mix of elevated and underground sections to navigate urban obstacles effectively.
The choice of alignment in Kanpur also reflects practical considerations; for example, underground sections were chosen in areas with high land-use density, ensuring minimal disruption to existing infrastructure and urban life. Such decisions are essential for maintaining a smooth operational flow while accommodating the needs of the community.
Financial Returns vs. Practical Considerations
While the alignment of metro lines ideally aims for the highest possible returns, practical considerations often influence the final design. Factors such as land availability, environmental impact, existing urban infrastructure, and socio-economic demographics play significant roles in alignment decisions. In many cases, the best theoretical alignment may not be feasible due to these constraints.
For instance, the Agra Metro project is being developed with an emphasis on maintaining a balance between accessibility and practical implementation. The first corridor, from Taj East Gate to Sikandra, includes both elevated and underground sections. This approach is not only designed to maximize ridership by connecting high-traffic areas but also to ensure minimal disruption to the city’s historic landscape, demonstrating UPMRC’s commitment to preserving the cultural heritage of Agra.
Agra Metro
Moreover, the NCMC card initiative exemplifies how UPMRC is also considering financial sustainability in its operational plans. By integrating ticketing across various modes of transport, UPMRC aims to enhance ridership, thus maximizing returns on investment while maintaining affordability for passengers.
In conclusion, the alignments of metro lines in Uttar Pradesh have been thoughtfully designed to address both operational efficiency and financial viability. While the objective of delivering the highest returns is a guiding principle, practical considerations have inevitably shaped the final decisions.
UPMRC’s strategic planning reflects a comprehensive understanding of urban dynamics, ensuring that the metro system not only serves immediate passenger needs but also supports long-term urban mobility goals. As these projects continue to unfold, their impact on transportation in Uttar Pradesh is set to transform urban mobility, contributing to a more efficient and sustainable future.
Rail Analysis: What construction/operational technologies help a metro deliver higher returns?
Shri Sushil Kumar: To deliver higher returns, metro systems like those developed by Uttar Pradesh Metro Rail Corporation (UPMRC) utilize a range of advanced construction and operational technologies that enhance efficiency, reduce costs, and improve the overall passenger experience.
Key Construction Technologies
One significant aspect of UPMRC’s approach is the use of modern construction techniques that enable faster project completion and cost savings. For instance, the implementation of prefabrication methods allows for the rapid assembly of structures, reducing both construction time and labor costs.
This is particularly evident in projects like the Lucknow and Kanpur metros, which were completed ahead of schedule. Such efficiency minimizes financial burdens and accelerates the return on investment, as operational services can commence sooner.
Operational Technologies
Once operational, several cutting-edge technologies contribute to the metro’s financial viability. Automatic Train Operation (ATO) is a standout feature that enhances safety and efficiency by minimizing human error. Trains operate under a centralized computer system, maintaining precise speeds and safe distances. This not only improves safety but also optimizes scheduling, allowing for more frequent service and increased ridership.
The Communication-Based Train Control (CBTC) system further enhances operational efficiency. It facilitates real-time communication between trains and trackside infrastructure, enabling closer train spacing without compromising safety. This results in reduced waiting times for passengers and greater capacity utilization, which is crucial in densely populated areas.
Smart Ticketing Solutions
In terms of passenger convenience, UPMRC has integrated online ticketing systems and mobile applications that streamline fare collection. This reduces the need for physical ticket counters and minimizes queuing times, enhancing the overall customer experience.
The introduction of the NCMC card promotes interoperability across various modes of transport, making it easier and more economical for commuters. This not only encourages higher usage rates but also fosters loyalty among passengers, contributing to sustained revenue growth.
Surveillance and Safety Measures
Moreover, advanced CCTV surveillance systems are implemented throughout stations and trains. These technologies ensure passenger safety and security, which is a critical factor in attracting and retaining commuters. By addressing safety concerns, UPMRC enhances trust in the metro system, further boosting ridership and revenue.
In summary, UPMRC employs a combination of modern construction techniques and operational technologies that significantly contribute to delivering higher returns. From rapid project completion to enhanced safety and convenience through automation, these technologies ensure a robust metro system that not only meets current demands but also positions itself for future growth.
As urbanization continues to rise, these advancements will play a pivotal role in transforming urban mobility in Uttar Pradesh and ensuring financial sustainability for metro operations.
Innovations and Awards
UPMRC is the second metro system to obtain energy (Purchase of cheap electricity) from the energy exchange. Currently, Lucknow and Kanpur receive power from the energy exchange at an economic rate.
The Lucknow metro has demonstrated merit by receiving the National Award of Excellence for being the metro rail service with the “best passenger service and satisfaction” from the Government of India, as well as the 15th Construction Industry Development Council Vishwakarma Award 2024 for the best construction project.
Multi-modal connectivity of UPMRC projects
Multimodal and last-mile connectivity is extremely important for metro rail projects. Chaudhary Charan Singh (CCS) Airport is just 92 metres from the CCS metro station, Lucknow. Heritage monuments and tourism hubs such as the Taj Mahal and the Red Fort are also connected by the Agra metro.
Agra Metro
Financial viability
To ensure the sustainability of metro operations, it is essential to identify and hand over land parcels to metro organisations to increase non-fare box revenue. Similarly, implementing a TOD policy with features beyond floor area ratio and land use changes, such as additional levies and duties for land near the metro network, is required as there has been an exponential increase in land prices.
“Lucknow Metro is in operational profit”
After commissioning, a 20-30 km metro rail network in a Tier II city requires Rs 1.25 billion-Rs 1.3 billion per year for day-to-day operations. The metro should be able to maintain a good cash-in/cash-out balance with a cash inflow of about Rs 1.5 billion per year from fare and non-fare box revenue models, which would its operational cost. Same applies to Lucknow Metro.
Currently, the average time taken from the conceptualisation and preparation of detailed project reports (DPRs) to the completion of metro corridors is 8-15 years. Further, constructing and operating one or two lines of about 30 km in Tier II cities has not significantly reduced road traffic congestion.
The construction of metro lines on main routes is also becoming difficult due to the continuous and rapid construction of flyovers. This has led some metros to build both metro lines and flyovers on the same pillars.
All Images Credit: UPMRC
This Interview is a part of our latest Magazine: Subscribe to our Magazine Today!
